Neo-conservatism is fading in America as George Bush gets ready to leave office in January. Far-rightist ideology, which is also an enemy to the Islamic ideology, is actually facing many problems across the West including Europe. Following are excerpts from an interview with Janusz Bugajski conducted by Hormoz Baradaran, from the Persian-daily “Iran“. Bugajski is the director of the New European Democracies Project in the US Center for Strategic and International Studies.
BARADARAN: Berlusconi’s win in Italian election added a new member to the club of European right-leaning governments. The failure of Britain’s New Labour in recent elections and by-elections in Wales and England created new grounds for the comeback of Tories. What are the root causes of right-resurgence in Europe?
BUGAJSKI: European politics usually passes through pendulum swings between center-right and center-left following national elections. Sometimes the pendulum moves more slowly and there is rarely synchrony across the continent as every country has its own political rhythm and election cycles.
Hence, what looks like a pattern of center-right victories may be largely a coincidence.
What are their political, social and economic approaches for resolving European problems?
I do not expect major policy changes in countries such as Italy or Britain. In general center-right governments tend to be more nationalist or protective of national sovereignty. However, even though this would be true if the Conservatives came back to power in Britain and could prove more resistant to further EU integration, the French, Italian, and German center-right does not differ markedly from the center-left on EU questions.
Right-wing governments and parties declare anti-immigration and fighting what they call Islamic terrorism as their core policy. Don’t you think that this in contradiction with the principles of the freedom of speech, human rights and has strained European ties with Islamic, African and Middle Eastern nations?
Anti-immigrant sentiments in parts of Europe are growing and in some countries they are promoted by radical parties, although not always the rightist ones. They are based on fears of losing national identity, job competition, and cultural differences. Islamophobia is also a factor largely because of simplistic perceptions depicting Islam as a terrorist ideology.
Such sentiments play into the hands of radicals and terrorist leaders who can claim that European governments are anti-Islamic. Much needed is a better understanding of the real principles of Islam and its essentially tolerant, respectful, and inclusive nature.
Some analysts say the rightist comeback will benefit Germany in context of EU politics. Germany, at present, is the most powerful EU member and is eager to lead Brussels’ diplomacy and other issues. A wave of EU membership gives Germany an exceptional opportunity to rule EU politics without serious barriers. What are these new opportunities?
I do not think Germany is in a position to lead Brussels or the EU especially as with 27 members the EU is much more diverse. France and Britain would certainly not allow Germany to play a dominant role and most of the new EU members are suspicious about Berlin’s close relations with a neo-imperialist Russia. In addition, Germany’s coalition government is very divided particularly as the Social Democrats control the foreign ministry while the Christian Democrats control the chancellorship.
While it seems that conservative and neo-conservative ideology is losing strength in the US, these approaches are gaining ground in Europe. Does this change effect transatlantic relations or top the balance of power?
Neo-conservatism as a foreign policy has certainly lost strength in the US But social conservatism and traditional conservatism remain potent forces in American politics. In Europe, conservatism is extremely varied and based on diverse national traditions. The major change in trans-Atlantic relations will be generated by the approach of the new US president who needs to rebuild a more productive alliance, closely consult with the Europeans, and restrict US unilateralism.
As with the center-left some center-right parties in Europe are less Atlanticist than others, while others favor a stronger American leadership.